Firefly III vs Maybe
| Tagline | Self-hosted personal finance manager with budgets, rules, and bank import | Modern open-source personal finance and net-worth tracking app you can self-host |
| Category | Finance & Budgeting | Finance & Budgeting |
| Replaces | Mint, YNAB, QuickBooks | Mint, YNAB |
| GitHub stars | 24k | 38k |
| Language | PHP | Ruby |
| License | AGPL-3.0 | AGPL-3.0 |
| Self-host difficulty | 3/5 Moderate | 2/5 Easy |
| Deploy options | Docker Docker Compose Manual | Docker Compose |
| Managed hosting | ||
| Last updated | 5 days ago | 1 month ago |
| View repo | View repo |
Where each falls short
The honest trade-offs — what you give up with each, versus the proprietary tools they replace.
Firefly III
- Bank import requires a separate importer container and CSV/OFX manipulation; no one-click bank sync
- UI can feel complex and verbose for casual users compared to Mint's simplicity
- No built-in mobile app; third-party apps exist but vary in quality
- Investment and brokerage account tracking is limited compared to dedicated wealth tools
Maybe
- Automatic bank sync (Plaid integration) requires API keys and third-party costs
- Investment data import limited compared to dedicated portfolio trackers
- Multi-user household support is still being developed
Bottom line
Choose Maybe if you want the lower-effort setup; choose Maybe for the larger community and ecosystem. Firefly III has seen more recent development. Open each guide below for deploy steps and the full feature gap.
Firefly III
Self-hosted personal finance manager with budgets, rules, and bank import
Maybe
Modern open-source personal finance and net-worth tracking app you can self-host